10 Movies That Made Redditors Feel Genuine Fear
seeing Terrorist 2 in the theater was a scary experience for many, and the smiles Take a smile they have also been disturbing. Whether one tries to watch every horror movie or wants to avoid the genre altogether, some movies have lasting effects and feel legitimately unsettling.
From stories about demonic possession to a home invasion slasher that looks like it could happen at any moment, Reddit fans have shared the movies that really scared them. For some, The ring it’s the scariest movie they’ve ever seen. It’s strange to imagine Samara Morgan walking out of a TV set with her long black hair.
Jaws (1975)
Rental on AppleTV
It’s easy to imagine jaws when you think of a movie with a beach vibe, as it is a classic. Redditor Thelawtman1986 posted that it really scared them, writing that “Honestly, they still get a little nervous in the dark water.”
Forever one of the best shark movies, there’s no denying how terrifying it is to watch characters wondering if they’re going to be attacked by a shark. The feeling of tension continues throughout the film. After watching jawsit’s hard not to worry about sharks when swimming in a lake or ocean.
Hereditary (2018)
Streams on Fubo and DirecTV
Hereditary has been celebrated thanks to writer/director Ari Aster’s dark portrait of a family unraveled by demonic possession. It is also considered to be absolutely creepy. Redditor Miepasie wrote that “the strange people in the background, the rawness, and a whole host of other elements in this movie make it like…a nightmare you’re just experiencing.”
Every member of the Graham family is haunted, and after Charlie’s unexpected death, the rest of the story is intense and fast-paced. While appreciating the art and talent behind the film, it’s understandable to find the visuals truly amazing.
The Exorcist (1973)
Stream on HBO Max
There are some classic horror movies that stick with audiences for years, thanks to vibrant, dark visuals that are impossible to move on from. Redditor babyform noted “The staircase scene goes in The Exorcist” and wrote, “I couldn’t go near the stairs for a hot minute after that.”
For some, watching Regan MacNeil writhe in a bed after a demonic possession is memorable. For others, it’s the scene where he got sick that sticks with them the most. Either way, The Exorcist it’s very disturbing
Barbarian (2022)
Stream on HBO Max
barbarian has been enthralling horror fans since its release in September 2022, thanks to a premise that turns out to be something different than what was assumed from the trailer. Redditor veechsingleton wrote: “I felt very tense and uncomfortable most of the time while watching.”
The shocking moments a barbarian are terrible as Tess Marshall stays in a rented house and discovers something in the basement. It’s easy to assume there’s darkness lurking in a stairwell or basement after looking.
Tusk (2014)
Stream on HBO Max
Body horror fans appreciate it tusk to tell a different story about a podcast host Howard meets, a man who lives alone and is obsessed with a walrus he once encountered. Written and directed by Kevin Smith, the film has some particularly gruesome and detailed scenes. One Redditor said, “I’ve been trying to put this movie out of my mind since I saw it. I didn’t realize how much body horror was scaring me until then.”
Although familiar with the horror subgenre I might find what happens to Wallace too intense. The film does not shy away from vivid and graphic images.
Paranormal Activity (2009)
Play on Paramount+
From Paranormal activity is a found footage story, it’s not hard to imagine living in a haunted house or apartment while watching it. Redditor Gooberflagm2 said that this movie “cracked me up. The idea of putting cameras in the house and seeing things move when they shouldn’t scare me…”.
The film does not have flashy, costumed slasher villains or an evil spirit that has been summoned for a specific reason. Instead, it suggests that many people live in houses that are haunted and have no idea.
The Grudge (2004)
Play on Paramount+
Redditor Sneakiee_Cat answered about movies that actually terrify them The grudge. The fan wrote: “I always washed my hair so fast and did double quick glances behind me to make sure there wasn’t a creepy ghost hand behind my head.”
Based on the Ju-On horror franchise, the 2004 American remake The grudge sees Karen living in Toyko and learning about a curse that has existed for a long time. Even those who don’t even move when there’s a jump scare can appreciate the fear of seeing a figure standing behind a character. That happens a lot in this movie.
The Strangers (2008)
Stream to Tubi
If most slashers start from the premise that a killer needs a reason to go after the main characters, then The Strangers turn that over in your head. A couple are staying in a country house when masked intruders appear and say they are killing them “because you were at home”. Redditor GrandmasNickname said the film “came a little too close for someone who lives alone”.
It feels easier to be truly afraid when you watch The Strangers than other horror films in the same subgenre because the killers are so casual and blasphemous about what they’re doing. It is undoubtedly one of the most disturbing concepts.
The Butterfly Effect (2004)
Stream on HBO Max
Redditor Appropriate_Might901 said “The butterfly effect“it really scared them. Many probably remember seeing this movie and being scared. While The butterfly effect it has confusing moments, it’s still terrifying as the main character finds himself in increasingly worse situations.
Since the main premise involves Evan Treborn seeing horrific tragedies, it’s understandable to find the story disturbing. Evan travels back in time when he reads the journal he kept as a child. When the past changes, it changes something else. Evan has seen so much pain that many scenes are brutal to watch.
The Ring (2002)
Play on Paramount+
Samara Morgan does The ring what a scary experience it is. Redditor concaveUsurper felt real fear when he saw, writing, “It didn’t help, I was too young and had an old CRT TV in my room that looked exactly like the one in the movie.”
Despite knowing that Samara is a fictional character from a movie, it’s easy to assume that she could really walk out of the TV and into the living room of whoever is tuning in. Samara’s scratched face and long hair have a strange effect.